The whole point of a system of rights and courts is that when the government wants to end your decades old business through administrative authority, they at least have to write a report on why, specifically — and they can’t claim that this is “new” to skip that step. That is what this ruling says.
Upholding laws and protection against government authority is also a good outcome.
I'm lamenting that the laws we have and the people enforcing them seem to bias towards profits at the expense of health. That is more important to make a small count people wealthy over a large number healthy.
Being able to hide your bullshit for a few years until it’s established being a way of avoiding a much harder process to win for you is bonkers.
Allowing businesses to create known health risks by illegally operating and then saying “well it isn’t new NOW” is idiotic and a horrible outcome.
In the same way, if a law requires backup cameras on new cars, the law applies to new cars not to a 1990 Lincoln.
[1] https://nepis.epa.gov/Exe/ZyNET.exe/P100LTG6.TXT?ZyActionD=Z...
If an agency wants to expand it's purview, it is the job of the legislative branch to change the law.
How come there can be green teams jackbooting grow rooms but there can't be a PFAS team jackbooting factories spewing known toxic substances into the environment?
Meanwhile, DuPont, 3C and other companies spend multiple millions of dollars on lobbying, political donations and bribery to ensure favorable laws and lax regulation. See the decision from the court in TFA - the concern for business overrides concern for public health.
It isn't crazy, it's just America. White supremacy and capitalism will always be the priority.
[0]https://eji.org/news/nixon-war-on-drugs-designed-to-criminal...
[1]https://www.foodandwaterwatch.org/2023/11/07/pfas-lobbying/
I seriously hope that your evaluation of these scenarios is based on the reality of their individual outcomes rather than “gubment bad durr”
I'm commenting on the fact that it's totally legal and feasible to do the war on drugs but when it comes time to muster that same kind of force against actual poisons being spewed into our environment all sorts of people trickle out of the woodwork to say that it's unconstitutional, infeasible, an overreach of power etc...