> But both come from the same authors.
The Git repository comes with a history containing each and every commit, along with checksums and sometimes cryptographic signatures for it all. The tarball is just a bunch of random files.
If somebody wants to rewrite the Git history, that will get instantly noticed by anybody that had an older clone of it. If somebody adds a hack to it, it will be at the top of the history and easy to notice as well.
If somebody adds something to a tarball, there is nothing to tell you that something changed, you'll have to audit the whole thing from top to bottom (or compare it to the Git repository it came from).
Also the author isn't in control here, the tarball can get changed after it was uploaded to the server and there would be nothing in the tarball itself to tell you.
People are using PGP signatures and checksums to secure tarballs some more, but that's always an extra step and doesn't happen automatically. And even that still doesn't give you the history.