Edit: to the question “How would you define a data broker for these purposes?” that was deleted, I would defer to the CFPB’s criteria:
https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/remarks-of...
Edit: to the question “How would you define a data broker for these purposes?” that was deleted, I would defer to the CFPB’s criteria:
https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/remarks-of...
I suspect that saying "no one should be able to sell people's data behind their back" would catch a lot more traction than "we should regulate this fuzzy idea of companies we don't think you should like." It would also solve the actual problem at hand.
Either way, the government accessing the data should absolutely require a warrant.
most importantly, it removes one potential lucrative buyer, making the business less profitable.
Because in practice, this bill does nothing.
Senior administration officials said the measure would blind U.S. intelligence outfits from getting information easily purchased by foreign intelligence operations
Right. And I'm supposed to believe that our intel people won't just use the data banks of British Intel or DGSE is that it?
Heck, our law enforcement people could use Homeland Security databases after the information is disseminated.
Without banning the practice of data aggregation in and of itself, you stop nothing.
ETA: Now I think about it, I guess it does stop a local sheriff from having his/her own database. But it does nothing to stop them from searching DHS databases and getting the same information. And of course, as far as federal intelligence and law enforcement, well, they would be custodians of the databases so... yeah.