Surge protectors do have one magical electrical thingy in them: metal oxide varistors (MOVs). They're what shunt current in an overvoltage transient and they do age with usage.
Either way, if your house has had a surge and other equipment has died that wasn't surge protected, probably a good time to replace all surge protectors in the house, they're not really meant to survive multiple large surges. They shunt the power destructively, just somewhere you don't care.
Is this a concern when buying used rackmount power conditioners (like used for live music setups?), to protect home IT gear? Can they be worn out without a sign that they are?