Excuse my ignorance but was it ever about the higher level of quality in education with the schools? I honestly thought the "getting in" aspect was the most important one.
I can only give you one data point, but I went to one of these "elite" universities (many years ago), and the quality of education I found there was really incredible. I honestly would not trade that for anything.
this is true. hard to fail but way very hard to get into Harvard.
What you get out depends on what you put in. Yes, you can skate through some of the top schools, but if on the other hand you want a top-tier education, you will definitely get it there.
You know what they call someone who graduates with a D average from Harvard? "A Harvard Graduate." The name brand itself opens the doors, I don't think too many care whether or not you skated through.