True exponential growth requires that everyone get richer over time, all the time, even the rich.
It would be wonderful for the world if Europe could grow as rich as the States, so I hope the article is right.
True exponential growth requires that everyone get richer over time, all the time, even the rich.
It would be wonderful for the world if Europe could grow as rich as the States, so I hope the article is right.
The rich getting richer (aka trickle down economics) is all fun and games until you have blood on the streets which is already happening in the US.
The EU formula (have the rich make their money where it's cheaper but still within the union) seems to be better on the long run but it won't be without significant pain either.
If Bob makes $5000 a month and Steve makes $10,000 a month, then the income disparity between those two individuals is $5000 a month. Now imagine the economy doubles in size and those gains are evenly distributed. Now Bob will be making $10,000 a month and Steve will be making $20,000, and the income disparity between the two will be $10,000 a month.
There's nothing trickling down in that scenario.
Except that's not we have in the US/EU/UK. The top earners have been increasing their share since the 1970s, if not longer. See, e.g.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-59565690
> since 1995, billionaires' wealth had risen from 1% to 3%.
> The world's richest 1% has taken more than a third of all additional wealth accumulated since 1995, while the bottom 50% captured just 2%.
> The researchers found that the world's 52 richest individuals saw the value of their wealth grow by 9.2% per year for the past 25 years, well above less wealthy social groups.
(That was just one of the page 1 results for "wealth inequality history" that I got. I know I've read better analyses that cover longer time periods before, but I'm feeling lazy at the moment. If you have any links at all to suggest we're in anything like "evenly distributed economic growth" then there's a possibility I'd be inclined to dive deeper.)
For instance, if I could press a button that would double my net worth while at the same time 5x-ing the net worth of my least favorite billionaire, I'd smash that button a million times a day.
What makes you think they are?
* China uplifted a ridiculous number of people out of poverty after they embraced free markets in 1990. [0] [1]
* Vietnam is doing the same thing right now.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deng_Xiaoping#:~:text=77%5D%3A...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_economic_reform#:~:tex...
Wealth compounds.
In nominal terms, the bottom 10% have no chance against the top 10%.
In percentage terms, the US is going on like ~5 straight years of the lower half doing relatively well: https://www.stlouisfed.org/open-vault/2024/feb/us-wealth-ine...
Just look at GDP graphs for the US, EU, and China over the past couple of decades.
You’ll see smooth upward exponential growth for US + China with a small bump in 2008. For the EU, it’s been nothing but wild gyrations, mostly trending sideways. Anyone from the World Bank, the IMF, and even tradingeconomics.com has this data.
The US economy is very robust, but politics have never been this bad.
https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2018/02/14/american...
There's this false narrative about the US being the bastion of social mobility, but it just doesn't hold up to facts. Europe does much better on this.
If you measured improvements in net worth as well, and measured it by the number of dollars added to someone's bottom line instead of just what quintile someone is in, it would be IMO a more fair comparison.
For example, (made up numbers ahead) let's compare two made-up people:
A is in the bottom quintile earning say 20k EUR with a net worth stagnating at 0 EUR, and they then move up to the top quintile earning 80k EUR with a net worth of 20k EUR and growing. They pay heavy taxes on that 80k EUR so it's hard to grow their wealth.
B is in the bottom quintile of the US, earning 20k USD. They make it up a couple of quintiles, but not quite to the top. They still end up earning 150k USD, and because they pay low tax, most of the 150k sticks around, giving them a net worth of say 50k USD and growing faster.
A will give a better indicator of social mobility according to the Economist's method.
But I'd much rather be B.