> The buyer of the carbon credits doesn't actually need the carbon to be captured. They just want a certificate for X credits, so they can emit elsewhere or get some other benefit.
This is correct, and I think works as intended.
The problem on the buyer's side is that the buyer has no incentive to emit no more than allowed by the certificates bought. This has to be verified, and the buyer punished for violation.
> The seller doesn't actually need to capture the carbon. As long as they can make a convincing enough case to the buyer that they did capture the carbon, the buyer is happy to buy.
The problem here isn't the buyer. Instead, the seller should have to prove that carbon has been captured before getting any carbon credits in the first place -- again, with punishment for violation.