The real culprit, or danger, as the article mentions, is not so much the change in materials and so on, but weaker standardization.
Bikes are still pretty good in this regard, but manufacturers seem to be increasingly producing proprietary parts and part sets, under the guise of innovation. They are not mutually exclusive - it's entirely possible to innovate while being modular and standardized, and in cases where not, create a new standard that everyone can work with.
I think electric bikes are a good example - all the mid-engine motors seem to have entirely different mounts, therefore requiring custom frames. And they seem to be bundled with proprietary electronics up to and including the UI. If this was all modular and standardized, you could pick and choose, and in fact a basic steel bike with electrics could be very sustainable - you may not even need gears, with the electric assist making up the effort as necessary.
I ask because “common sense” would be invalidated by the parents submitted data already, so I don't think applying “common sense” is wise.
> It's important to note that not all e-bikes are created equal when it comes to exercise benefits. The study found that class 1 e-bikes, which provide pedal assistance up to 20 mph, were the most effective at promoting physical activity. This is because riders still have to pedal and put in some effort to maintain a consistent speed. In contrast, class 2 e-bikes, which have a throttle that allows riders to cruise without pedaling, were found to be less effective at promoting exercise.
I agree with the "common sense" thing, which is why I read the citation.
TL;DR: class 1 electric bikes assist you with peddling, unlike class 2, meaning you can go longer and farther and therefore do more exercise than on a traditional bike.