Is this just the “I need validation by other people liking what I like” thing we see a lot in gaming, sports, etc. fandoms?
What I’m also curious about, given how shocking it is for Apple to totally miss the mark, is if this was calculated.
Is this just the “I need validation by other people liking what I like” thing we see a lot in gaming, sports, etc. fandoms?
What I’m also curious about, given how shocking it is for Apple to totally miss the mark, is if this was calculated.
I think this is right. The ad is about the flattening of the old analog world into the digital one and it evokes strong feelings because our nostalgia for that is not a little about a real and significant loss, which the Apple commercial grotesquely celebrates.
The ad visibly destroys items associated with creativity and culture, celebrates such destruction, and replaces it with an iPad. It reminded me of that scene in Pinocchio where the boys trash the mansion and the piano in it, it reminded me of book burnings. It could easily be understood as "screw the old world, it's all in our product now."
And to a demographic of Apple buyers who actually tend to like culture, who are more likely than the average to attend actual concerts, visit a gallery or enjoy their vinyl collection, that was highly, highly offensive.
Contrast that with Steve Jobs "It is a music player, it is a computer, it is a phone" skid from the iPhone introduction: Back then, it was not about replacing music players, it was a music player. The product was a tool, not the end. With the ad, the product is the end, not the tool.
As Alan Kay said "A change in perspective is worth 80 IQ points." Apple lost their perspective. The worst thing about it is that it plays into a very old caricature of tech geeks - giving everyone a bad name.
When does Apple expect a Vivaldi concert to feature the pianist only turning up with an iPad instead of a Grand? Same for all the tools on display in the add.
We were doing a focus group that went slightly off the rails and a room full of people all agreed that the bank must still have paper records.
The bank had not had paper records for decades.
Im not sure that "nostalgia" is the right word...
This comes across as rather belittling to me - akin to calling someone a "snowflake" for not acquiescing to someone else's version of reality. It is possible to find the theme of the ad to objectionable in a way that transcends the personal: for example, out of concern for the possible consequences of coarsening commercial speech, or of promoting the devaluation of human creativity. I really don't think that many of the critics were demanding a personal apology.
I see a lot of comments expressing the former, and a lot of comments reacting against the latter. Are you sure that's an accurate representation of the reaction?
> Is this just the “I need validation by other people liking what I like” thing we see a lot in gaming, sports, etc. fandoms?
Internet forums? ;)
How many people have a painting set, or a musical instrument, and dream of getting good at it but just can't be bothered because they'd rather watch ads online?