All of my 'extracurricular' activities that turned out to be useful/productive/important were not organized in any way by adults. I think many people are arguing that students should have more free time available to develop their own interests.
and yes, in fact, volunteering at a hospital should be viewed favorably for pre-med.
and yes, you will be a better student if you play some kind of team sport like softball than if you did nothing.
so perhaps the comment i was replying to made bad arguments? for example, if a school only liked mainstream athletics and ignored anything else (which is probably not a stretch), that would be a better example of "having their heads up their asses".
but the specific examples given were the opposite - they actually make sense.