If WhatsApp/FB Messenger and iMessage added the government as a hidden group member to all our conversations tomorrow, and the day after that Signal was removed from the app marketplaces due to not complying, >99% of people would loose E2EE.
We would go back to how it was in the early 2000's, 99% of people used Yahoo/AOL/MSN "normally" and people like us would dabble with Jabber/XMPP off-the-record. In some ways it would be easier today, the cryptographic libraries and standards are better and invented. In other ways it would be much more difficult. Undoubtedly Ylva Johansson would be happy!
(I hate to bring up crypto currencies. But it's similar. It's impossible to make crypto currencies disappear, but it's fairly simple to make them marginalised and/or not effective as privacy tools by introducing stringent KYC measurements at the intersection between crypto currencies and the normal economy. Sure, you can always buy drugs on the darkweb and food at anarcho capitalist festivals, but it will never have any real privacy impact on real people in their everyday lives.)