For starters, it features a guy blaming his wife for a decision. Sounds like a certain Supreme Court justice. It is inherently bullshit.
Separately, corporate communications are as much about what you don't talk about as what you do.
Paul Graham probably wishes he could turn back the clock, and never fire Altman from YC in the first place.
They would have loved to have Altman be the figurehead of YC at this time.
I'm sure they had these conversations for months: "You can come back to YC as a figurehead president." The conversations went nowhere. Maybe YC was ready to genuflect, ready to co-administer the OpenAI startup fund, which is obviously Altman's BANTA. Like why deal with YC at all, when Altman could administer an index on all AI startups better than they can? That's what happened. What's in it for this billionaire Altman to generate wealth for YC LPs, at this stage?
The best Graham could do was this tweet. YC is not yet an index on all the best AI startups. End of story. This is an existential crisis for them. They are of course a great organization who sincerely care about people succeeding, but so do many accelerators and venture studios. So it's very hard to see this play out.
Sam Altman was incomprehensibly lucky. His feet which people stepped on were constantly connected to his ass which they had to kiss tomorrow. His executive collaborators also were people whose feet were stepped on and whose ass now gets kissed. Satya Nadella - the CEO of a far more successful and influential company - has to kiss these asses!
He even got fired from OpenAI - of course the science PhDs were right, he had to go, what's wrong with you people, you should always be on Team PhD - and yet again you must kiss his ass after stepping on his toes. The OpenAI board got mocked in the media, implications of being unqualified, with all the associated sexism, for doing their jobs correctly! Sounds like a certain toxic politician.
Truthfully, all of his antagonists should stop wasting their time worrying about this guy. Anthropic is likely to be very successful. Work for them! There are alternatives. It took only a year for competition to force OpenAI to make its core offering free. All the Thrive ass kissers may yet have bought billions of dollars of units of OpenAI that will turn out to be worth far less than they bargained for. Time will tell.