No, ideas are a dime a dozen. You seem to think of ideas as "thought + action" but then it's not an idea anymore; it's a real product with an idea behind it. Your example of your dad is a perfect example of why ideas really are a dime a dozen. That mantra isn't about saying that ideas themselves are worthless, it's about the idea that ideas alone with no action are worthless. I think the mantra stands as correct still.