Most of his reasons sound stupid, maybe im just biased(because i love vim) but his list of textmate problems was much more concrete and to the point than the vim one. So vims problems are that its cryptic, its not a complete picture and it requires you to learn a language to script it. Those sound absurd reasons, i think he is just trying to find himself reasons to ignore textmates problems, which is not that bad, i do the same with vim(emacs is uncomfortable and elisp is retarded, textmate is proprietary and runs only on the mac...)