It's almost impossible to have a rational discussion of anything Tesla now. The words Tesla and Elon bring far too much toxicity.
At the root of the Musk hate seems to be the fact that he (loudly) doesn't subscribe to a handful of political positions that some folks have adopted as axiomatic in their moral worldview. They essentially see him as a heretic, and attack him for stuff that others get a pass on. I mean, Zuckerberg made his billions spying on everyone and destroying the mental health of teenagers. His businesses have a tiny fraction of the socially redeeming value of Musk's. But Zuck doesn't get a fraction of the hate Musk does.