You specify present-day academia. Do you feel as though there was a point in the past where this wasn't true? If so, when, and why do you think it's changed?
My guess is pre-Moon Landings, pre-Peer Review and pre-DoEd.
What does the moon landing have to do with it?
Nothing, it's a reference to the period not the event itself. Something went wrong in Academia sometime between the 60's and 80s, to the point where papers today routinely get both peer-approved and simultaneously can't be reproduced. Something is very wrong with our ethics.
Is there data on the reproducibility of papers both pre- and post- the alleged academic shift?