Of course we are not separate species since successful interbreeding did happen (when the populations interacted).
That's fine in general. Many words are like that. But it makes it flawed as a scientific concept.
It's really unfortunate that schools tend to simplify the definition of species in this way, because it's just not really not meaningfully true at all. We could "make" it true by actually defining species this way (at least for animals) but it'd radically transform our taxonomies.