So I quite support the requirement that people explicitly enable it.
Remember the DNT is voluntary - but if everyone does it by default, then there is nothing left to track, so websites will have no interest in paying attention to the flag.
So I quite support the requirement that people explicitly enable it.
Remember the DNT is voluntary - but if everyone does it by default, then there is nothing left to track, so websites will have no interest in paying attention to the flag.
Isn't that the whole point? Websites may not have interest in tracking disabling policies, but a lot of people do. Maybe these advertising companies ought to incentivize users to opt-in to sell their data instead of the other way around.
I can see Google fully implementing DNT on the basis that users don't care, and for the few that do they're happy to comply
But making it default to on, especially if no one gives a damn is the death knell to the whole business model
Suddenly you have to pay for everything.
Although I would be interested in using DNT if out had more granular control to block certain entities
I wonder if we'll see sites who honor the header, but require that it be off in order to access content.
Instead they can show a banner that DNT is enabled and when it is disabled, the banner is gone.
False dichotomy. It's not "targeted ads vs no content on the internet". People will just have to use generic ads, not targeted ones. I don't think there will be any meaningful difference in profit, and even if there is, then so be it.
I think a couple other posters here have pointed out the larger problem - without ads like this, the free internet dries up and suddenly you need to start paying for everything from gmail to facebook (or whatever other tools/blogs/webcomics any of us visit).