I think we'd be better off with exchange taxes. Every time assets, securities, currency, etc is exchanged... it gets taxed. This includes stock trades. Property taxes are a way to make people not actually own their property.
I think we'd be better off with exchange taxes. Every time assets, securities, currency, etc is exchanged... it gets taxed. This includes stock trades. Property taxes are a way to make people not actually own their property.
How do you figure? What does ownership have to do with taxation?
That's kind of the point here, isn't it? To the people proposing this, that's a feature, not a bug.
You think it's a bug. Fine. But if you oppose it, saying "but it will actually do what it was designed to do!" is not an effective counterargument.
Yes, you have. You keep repeating it, like you think saying it ends the argument.
The problem that people are trying to address is wealth inequality. They want something that affects the rich more than everyone else - more than linearly. The problem with all your "points of interaction" is that they don't do that. They especially don't touch someone who has 10 billion dollars and just sits on it - leaves it invested in the same thing, maybe for decades, and doesn't spend nearly in proportion to their wealth.
What do you have to say to the people who are trying to address wealth inequality, other than just repeating that you don't think they should do that? Do you have anything that might actually make them change their minds?
You might have chosen to pay your property taxes monthly, through escrow, and thus 1/12 of your property tax is sent along with your mortgage principal and interest every month, but your actual mortgage numbers aren't changing.
Nobody should have property removed simply for living another year.
edit: property taxes are actually up about 400% over when I bought my home 6 years ago. They property evaluation is now close to market value, where it was much lower/less and historically had been. It's been a money grab. It's also been particularly hard on retired home owners.
I bought my house in 2015 for $340K, it's estimated to be worth $550-600K now, but my property tax is on only $275K in value. Each year, that value goes up 3%. It was taxed based on a ~$210K value when I bought it.
In this case though, "new buyer" will only refer to new construction. A buyer of an existing house keeps the assessed value. It doesn't jump.