Also, I suspect there are a couple of reasons such studies are uncommon in computer science. For one, CS isn't really a science; programmers and computer scientists are not trained in the scientific method or experimentation (beyond their general education); almost no CS papers I've read have contained empirical studies. If anything, they are closer to math papers than science papers!
Additionally, this sort of study is basically sociology. (Or something similar.) These sorts of fields are considered a little shady by hard scientists, and CS people tend to empathize more with the latter. I think this explains the immediate attack on methodology.
All that said, having more studies done about these questions would be great. I'm just not sure who's the best to do them. Maybe HCI researchers? I can't help thinking that the really intense PL people I know wouldn't be very interested in doing this.