The only problem is, people have been doing these experiments for 30 years, and do you know what the net effect it's had on the world of programmers: none at all. Saying "no no, this time really listen to this study" seems to be having no effect.
There are a lot of causes for this, not least of all the things you mention (nobody cares about science, people like or dislike based on non-scientific evidence).
But it's also because people know that all these studies are flawed. As much as I hate to be the "nitpicker" who takes apart studies, EVERY SINGLE STUDY on programming doesn't even come close to real-life scenarios. In fact, one of the few studies that people actually believe is the "some programmers are 10x better" study, and that was actually fairly well conducted - many students were given identical tasks, and a fairly large amount of time to do them.
But take a look at the Dynamic vs. Static argument. For years, the Dynamic-fans have been saying "Quicker to program, so it's better", while the Static-fans have been saying "Quicker to program, but harder to maintain, hard to use with large teams". So now we have a study that doesn't even come close to addressing most of the issues that have been argued for years! Of course this isn't going to convince anyone.