not my argument, not my words, quoted from from TFA.
> has that been applied to animals?
yes 100% it has.
> Does a dog communicate with his trainer with the depth and accuracy that an athlete does?
yes. i'm more familiar with horses, but the connection between rider/trainer and horse is very deep and precise. people build walls.
your points 1 - 4 are 100% applicable to animals just as well
in my opinion, point 5 is solidly won by the animal athletes
> Human minds are far more capable than horse minds, and so can have goals and make tradeoffs that horse minds are incapable of.
precisely. mind, and will, is not an advantage for raw performance. that's why for example donkeys and mules don't perform like horses - they are technically smarter.
> Do horses make plans for the future?
nope. not at all. they 100% live in the moment. they just like to run and love to do what they're asked to. do you see how, for an athlete, that is the almost perfect thing? it takes humans a lot of training to let their minds blank and get "in the zone". we fight against our minds sometimes.
i'm not saying human smarts or will is not an "advantage" overall. but for going fast? not necessarily. it's just not a "A huge advantage" to running.
Walter, i've enjoyed the back/forth. i also really appreciate the things you have done and created, btw. i'm not trying to be argumentative, but i am trying to expose you to how awesome these animal athletes are. really they are extraordinary. they are, in fact, the real-life dragons and mythical creatures we romanticize, and for once it's not an exageration. perhaps it's difficult to convey, but if you ever can, find a good horse to hang out with. they blow people away. even a bog average horse (or a dog) is 1000% the friend and has at least 1000% the heart of anyone you'll know.