Hacker News Reader

Comment by Alupis | Hacker News Reader

It's not the water that's the issue generally - it's the minerals in the water.

The article author got lucky this time - when electronics die from water contact, it's usually the minerals bridging connections and creating shorts. Letting the device dry does not remove those shorts. Some places have such hard water (lots of minerals) that evaporated water leaves calcium, limestone and other deposits on the surface of everything it's touched.

Does that mean doing it once will always cause an issue? Of course not... but repeatedly doing this, and/or becoming used to washing electronics in the dishwasher is a recipe to ruin them in the long term.

I would not personally want to play games with a toaster that can be replaced for $20 at your local Walmart...

View on HN

Would mineral deposits be sufficiently large and conductive that they would cause an actual issue between components?

They would probably represent nothing more than minor stray resistance/capacitance.

Assuming it was conductive enough, a scales bridge between higher voltage parts would just represent a path of material a few microns thick that would vaporize as soon as the toaster would be plugged in.

For other electronic devices, any component with a hole, like a microphone, barometric, humidity sensor, or mechanical (HDD), is more likely to suffer a more permanent fate. If water gets inside a relay housing, chemicals from the washing liquid may damage or gunk the contacts and reduce their life. LCD screens, glued parts and thin plastics don't fare well in dishwashers either...

>Would mineral deposits be sufficiently large and conductive that they would cause an actual issue between components?

A good proportion of water-damaged cellphones can be revived just by washing the logic board thoroughly in isopropyl alcohol. It's possible that this is due to small amounts of water trapped in crevices, but I've seen it work on boards that looked bone-dry under the microscope.

Crevices could be inside components. Alcohol will extract the water by diluting it and then evaporating

A lot of household appliances use potted relays and conformal coatings. If you pull the control board out of your clothes washer you'll see what I mean. It's particularly important because the control board is often within spitting distance of a solenoid that's holding back 60-80 psi of water.

> Would mineral deposits be sufficiently large and conductive that they would cause an actual issue between components?

> They would probably represent nothing more than minor stray resistance/capacitance.

Spoken like someone who has never maintained any electronic devices. Skepticism should err on the side of risk management.

A toaster (at least a cheap toaster) is an electrical device, not an electronic one, as stated by the author in the article. Please look up the difference if you don't know what it is.

We have toasters that run linux, connect to the internet, and play doom. Explain to me how they aren't electronic devices.

Even cheap toasters (I take toaster apart for fun) have true electronics these days because it's usually cheaper to implement things like timers electronically and if the toaster has a display it certainly has some electronics. But I suspect that the absolute simplest toasters are purely mechanical and electrical.

Most toasters these days actually use a PT8A2514A (https://www.diodes.com/assets/Datasheets/PT8A2514A.pdf) microcontroller. But it is still safe to wash, for the same reason as it is usually safe to wash a keyboard.

It's not every day you see a datasheet with a "bagel" in the diagram.

I was curious so I did some searching -- this is the cheapest toaster that I'm aware of in the US, and it surprisingly does have a custom IC that handles the timing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zLFG068HtgM

A $20 something you are about to throw away is the perfect thing to play games with.

It’s the fire risk that’s the issue not 20$.

To be fair, a toaster is always a fire risk. That's why the manual says never put them under flammable things. You should always assume your toaster will catch fire.

The toaster body itself may not be a big deal, but the cord and plug are also going to be a risk here.

What fire risk if it's in a dishwasher? :)

You only save money if you plug it in afterwards. At which point residue poses a fire risk.

Also, many dishwashers have a garbage disposal which isn’t inside the water and may fail if the cord gets into it. Not likely to happen, but enough people try it and someone may directly get an electrical fire while the dishwasher is running.

dried calcium carbonate is not a very good conductor, and neither calcium carbonate nor calcium oxide is deliquescent

(edit: i said 'calcium chloride' which is of course both wrong and irrelevant)

i think the bigger issue with electronics is overheating their electrolytic capacitors

you do realize the reason why fires get started is because things become a BAD conductor right?

it's not that simple. it's because things are medium bad conductors, like the nichrome wire in the toaster, which is absolutely fantastic for setting things on fire

things that are really good conductors like the copper wires in the toaster don't heat up (much) because they don't drop much voltage, and things that are really bad conductors, like the panels that support the nichrome wires and like calcium carbonate, don't heat up at all, because they don't carry any current. it's the things that are in between that cause fires: they can carry enough current to be a problem, while also dropping enough voltage to be a problem

this has been introductory electrical engineering 101. i'll be here all week, don't forget to tip your server, and read chapters 1 of horowitz & hill by monday

that's partially true; however, I still think I was right.

yes, there are places that don't heat up because the current doesn't go through them, but only because they have easier paths. if the electricity wanted to go through them, they would heat up hotter than anything else.

the point is, things can corrode, electricity goes in places it wasn't intended or through resistances it wasn't intended, and becomes a fire hazard.

Why not play such games? If it works, it works; if it fails, it only costs $20 to replace at your local Walmart!

Because failure modes of toasters may include fire.

A toaster is normally filled with dessicated carbohydrate particles, which are an explosive fire risk.

I would think going through dishwasher would significantly reduce the fire risk.

And once you start using it again they begin replenishing.

Except now the toaster may or may not be compromised in some way. There’s no amount of benefit here worth even a minuscule risk of a house fire.

After you take it out of the dishwasher, rinse it with distilled water, then let it dry.

totally agree, I had an electrical device catch on fire because of this exact instance

Once electronics gets wet (like stuff you plug into a wall), it usually should be discarded for safety's sake.

edit: its not just that, the water causes the copper to oxidise and swell, touching places it shouldnt

Reply on news.ycombinator.com