Separating men and women in such an environment is sensible. Recognizing that isn't victim blaming.
Separating men and women in such an environment is sensible. Recognizing that isn't victim blaming.
This is completely wrong. War has fairly strict rules, actually, more strict than policemen in the US.
I can tell from your comments you've never been in a firefight and your political leanings.
War has rules of engagement, yes. But both sides have to agree to abide by them. But I can guarantee that in the heat of battle any rules go out the window and survival is all you care about. An emotion afterwards is all there is, especially when you are young and undereducated. You ideals don't mean much.
People seem to think in this thread I'm trying to make excuses for this behaviour. I'm not. I'm providing reasons.
Eh... no. Watch a few clips from Ukraine-Russia war, what those soldiers are doing. The movies are on Reddit. This has nothing to do with any rules, Geneva Conventions or whatever. War rules are only there in order to make people like you happier, but if war happens, they're out of the window.
Disclosure: 12 years in military multiple tours of various warzones.
How recently? I'm guessing, recently enough that the military you served in is the dysfunctional military described in the article, which suffers from a severe lack of leadership. People whose service was further in the past can tell you a very different story.
I can agree with basically everything you've said, bar the assumption that the military is only recently dysfunctional. A brief look at any period of history will mostly show you a severe lack of proper leadership with very few exceptions.
I'm aware my experience isn't everyone's.
Unpopular as the reality might be, when you train people to be killers, in the lowest ranks many of whom are there instead of in gangs or jail, because there's no other options for them, don't be shocked that within that subset of the population you finding high rates of various crimes, especially violent ones.
Or does the inability of soldiers to control themselves mysteriously only apply to subordinates, women, and civilians?