This makes a lot of sense, because for the most part, you only go looking for bugs when you've run into a problem.
Looking for bugs you haven't run into is a lot harder (especially in complex software like OpenSSL), you might get lucky and someone sees a bug while looking for something else, but mostly things go unlooked at until they cause a problem that attracts attention.
Even when you pay for a professional audit, things can be missed; but you'll likely get better results for security with organized and focused reviews than by hoping your user base finds everything.