Like it or not, it's effectively a federal ID. Look at some old state drivers licenses and they would be laughably easy to forge today without even photos. And that's not even getting into the back-end information exchange.
I mean, if your position is that state IDs shouldn't really mean much, that's fine. But say that. But without REAL ID we'd require at least passport cards for air travel and a lot of other federal-related purposes. Which is fine I guess but probably a more expensive and heavyweight process than it needs to be.