There are ~2400 NFL players in the US, which means about 1 in 140k people.
If you figure that 10% of the people care enough about football to make an attempt, then someone who is in the 99th percentile of that group of people--someone I think many people would call undeniably good at the game, then they still have to be at least 99th percentile among those people to actually have a go of making it as a career.