only then can it be trustworthy, fast and free/accessible
only then can it be trustworthy, fast and free/accessible
On the other hand things like SMTP truly are ancient. They were designed to do things that just aren’t a thing today.
If you can't trust DNS, you can't trust TLS or anything downstream of it.
Even banks are not bothering with EV certificates any more, since browsers removed the indicator (for probably-good reasons). DV certificate issuance depends on trustworthy DNS.
Internet security is "good enough" for consumers, most of the time. That's "adequately trustworthy", but it's not "very trustworthy".
However, I don't think it's reasonable to call DNS, as a system, "very trustworthy".
"Well-secured" by active effort, and consequently "adequately trustworthy" for consumer ecommerce, sure.
But DNS is a systemic weak link in the chain of trust, and must be treated with extra caution for "actually secure" systems.
(E.g., for TLS and where possible, the standard way to remove the trust dependency on DNS is certificate pinning. This is common practice, because DNS is systemically not trustworthy!)
I think you're "well-secured" comment is saying the same thing I am, with some disagreement about "adequate" vs "very". I don't spend any time worrying that my API calls to AWS or online banking transactions are insecure due to lack of DNSSEC, so the DNS+CA system feels "very" trustworthy to me, even outside ecommerce. The difference between "very" and "adequate" is sort of a moot point anyway: you're not getting extra points for superfluous security controls. There's lots of other things I worry about, though, because attackers are actually focusing their efforts there.
As always, it ultimately depends on your threat profile, real or imagined.
Re: certificate pinning, it's common practice in the financial industry at least. It mitigates a few risks, of which I'd rate DNS compromise as more likely than a rogue CA or a persistent BGP hijack.