Also what are the 72 genders you had in mind specifically?
> Also what are the 72 genders you had in mind specifically?
The first Google result for "number of genders" gives 72!
https://www.medicinenet.com/what_are_the_72_other_genders/ar...
Not everyting is good for kids who lack of knowledge and life experience
The reality is that some children are Asian. Their own parents and siblings may be one of those kinds of people. They will encounter those kinds of people in their daily lives right now. They will probably have questions about them and the differences between those people and others. It's good for curious children to be able to explore and learn about the world around them. Why create arbitrary limits on what kinds of people they can or cannot learn about?
Obviously any kind of material, entertainment/cultural or educational, should be age appropriate and fortunately very few children are interested in literature written for a much older audience. If some 6 year old has the attention span and ability to understand complex works by all means let them read them. It's also the job of teachers and parents to contextualize and discuss with children the complex topics they are interested in exploring, not to hide it from them entirely so that they stay ignorant.
Besides, children will go through puberty, and they will get to experience a whole lot of hormonally driven urges which, it may surprise you, have quite a lot to do with sex.
Want to promote teen pregnancies, STDs, unrealistic views of sex gleaned from porn, and ignorance about sex, consent, and intimacy? Then ban books and any other publicly scrutinized sources of knowledge suitable for them, and just let them figure it out themselves.
We help children learn about society, language, maths, and science, but sexuality is somehow off-limits?
As of today there are many concepts or things that society decided that arent good for kids and they are 18/21 age restricted.
And now: is the topic of transgender people important and appropiate for them? I'd say no. Transgender people are very, very tiny population and the topic itself is milion times overblown by media.
Changing gender may easily fuckup your life and % of the cases where it is viable idea is tiny
She was prescribed testosterone at her first appointment with Planned Parenthood. There was basically no gatekeeping.
Avoid talking about any and all things you deem uncomfortable and strange. Reject the identity and existence of millions of people until it's "appropriate".
Maybe we should ship all transgender people to a reservation so that children don't interact with them until it's age appropriate? It's so simple!
I have no idea what kind of damage to my idea of self this kind of information being pushed onto me would have caused, especially when at that time I was the bullied kid for being short and nerdy, girls especially would always mock me for that reason. Maybe it would have caused none. I always saw school as lame, I did the bare minimum and always had good grades. Maybe it would have been a class that I just didn't pay any attention to.
It was a different time back then though. The Internet only became a thing when I was already 13, and at that point things had changed quite a bit for me.
Kids these days seem to be exposed to some... er... "objectionable" material a lot earlier. Now that I am a father, I do worry about what kind of information my daughter will receive once she grows up and goes to school. Not sure how people deal with this sort of stuff nowadays.
When I was a kid, a parent on the radio said this about gay marriage: "I am the gatekeeper for what is socially acceptable for my child."
I asked my Dad about that statement, and he said pretty clearly "That's an unrealistic expectation of what parenthood is. You're more of a bodyguard or secret service. You can listen and provide context, do your best to stop your child from being put into danger, but you cannot stop, control or manage a child's, much less a teenagers, world experience."
Back in the day a parent was absolutely the gatekeeper of what was socially acceptable to a child. Nowadays, probably less so.
Teenagers were always uncontrollable. Try to control them and they will defy you. I know I did, and essentially every other teenager I came in contact with.
I became an atheist when I was a teenager. Before that the idea of religion was just something taught to me by my parents. I was taught to pray and that there was a God above, and all that. (It was actually a bit more complicated than that, as my parents had different religions each).
I was, however, given the freedom to explore my own ideas about religion and to develop my own views about the world once I was a little older. Honestly, I think they handled it all quite well.
For that matter, if my daughter decides to be religious once she grows up a little, she will also have my support.
My way to view this is that while she is a baby and later a small girl I am fully responsible for her. As she grows up, the more I will be on the background, and her own ideas will take the center stage instead. As I usually say "I'll teach her everything I can, she will learn everything she wants".
It is a typical progressive tactic to censor things and then attack a strawman argument.
> The legislation also explicitly bans books depicting sexual acts from K-12 libraries and classrooms
12th grade. So 17yo? Ye. No reading about 'sexual acts' for you. They better watch porn instead of reading romantic novels I guess?
There’s a glut of material telling very young kids that they’re the wrong gender or gay. No 7 year old is anything other than what their parents tell them. If they had their way, they would be fairy dinosaurs.
I have small children and have been to the local library and it hadn't changed much. Nothing edgy but a strange book about different kind of feces I kinda found distasteful.
Many books make you wonder what the authors were high on while painting. But that is an old question.
There are books with 'two mums' children. But I guess you are describing something else, like some sort of over the top push?
There has to be some consensus among the school, school library and parent body, about what in general should be in the library.
If the state think it needs to take action there is a deeper problem and they are just virtue signaling.
Please could you give an example of this?
This was featured at my local regional library in the area for kids 5-10. Look through the “readers also enjoyed” and I’ve seen books either like that or those books exactly in kids sections.
My closest library is the same, possibly worse since the selection is smaller but they seem to have every gender bent book ever released.
It also looks very much like it's targeted at teens and young adults. Amazon lists the reading age as "16-17 years" [0]. If it's in the 5-10yo section, I would say that's the library's mistake rather than a push from the trans community.
[0] https://www.amazon.co.uk/Kisses-Jet-Coming-Gender-Story/dp/1...
My kids often say they’re animals. They’re not. They’re kids, so they play pretend.
I personally know parents telling their kids that they are the wrong gender. The kids are 3-6. It’s child abuse.
Not sure what you mean by this... are you accusing them of deliberately under-aging trans related books?
> Telling a child they may be something they’re not
This is already a weaker statement than "telling kids they're the wrong gender". And I don't think that the linked book even goes that far. "Some kids feel this way" is very different to "you feel this way" and 16-17 year olds are normally smart enough to tell the difference.
> I personally know parents telling their kids that they are the wrong gender.
That sounds awful. Although to be frank I wonder if you're also making this sound worse than is actually the case. Either way I'm not sure it's relevant.
Do you actually believe they are, or are you just repeating the right-wing outrage memes?
> They aren't supposed to care about these things and it just confuses them.
K-12 in the US means education up to and including 12th grade. That's (roughly) 17 year olds at the far end. Puberty starts quite a bit before that.
Of course, for preteens learning about sexual orientations makes sense. Quite a lot of people are queer you know, and that's not a crime at the moment (although I'm sure that is something some people in Iowa would like).
(The question why schools should allow pornographic books for anyone still remains, but is not relevant in this context.)