> That's the challenge being presented, why isn't the societal default to call a child "They" until they identify with a particular pronoun?
I don't know. I don't make the rules. I just follow. What I can tell is that challenging the rules come at a price. I don't want to impose that price on my daughter. If she wants to challenge societal rules (against my advice) when she is old enough to do so, she will have my support.
> Have you asked them if they like dresses over pants? Do they like trains over dolls?
Asking her things now is foolish. She is only months old.
If she prefers playing with cars and trains rather than dolls, I will buy her cars and trains.
To be frank, I think all those are lame. I will try to nudge her into liking puzzles, board games, painting, that sort of stuff. And later on videogames. I dream of the day she will be old enough to play Mario Kart with me and beat me.
> I'm not criticizing your parenting style or approach, but this should be about about them, not society or you or your wife
I agree, but that will be at an age when she can meaningfully build her own idea of self. Right now she cries when her nappies are dirty, and likes when I make her sleep walking arond the bedroom holding her against my chest. I don't think she can mount an intellectual defense about her own gender identity, or about religion, or any such complex subjects.