Especially if they have a fraught relationship with the provider of those free services.
System76 provides the PopOS repos that are based on Ubuntu. They don’t freeload.
Canonical provides the Ubuntu repos that are based on Debian. They don’t freeload.
WP Engine is freeloading, no doubt about it.
If the bandwidth/infra costs to support all of WPEngines customers were so much, then they must have, right?
If they were asked and refused that's certainly one thing. If they were never asked, and then when they refused the demands for money.. then it looks like matt was just looking for a wrench to hit them with and this one came to mind.
No need to ask someone with common sense who is already doing it.
At least for Ubuntu, the packages they distribute generally don't have the same checksum as Debian, so they're not the same packages (at least as binaries).
Also, "wordpress.org" is hard-coded as the plugin repo source all over WordPress.