I don’t understand how people can so confidently make claims like this. We might underestimate how difficult AGI is, but come on?!
I don’t understand how people can so confidently make claims like this. We might underestimate how difficult AGI is, but come on?!
Evolution created intelligence and consciousness. This means that it is clearly possible for us to do the same. Doesn't mean that simply scaling LLMs could ever achieve it.
Related discussion (from 2016): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11729499
Quantum theory states that there are no passive interactions.
So there are real obstacles to replicating complex objects.
Can we being inside our brain fully understand our own brain?
Similar with can we being inside our Universe fully understand it?
We can study brains just as closely as we can study anything else on earth.
Also don't forget that many suspect the brain may be using quantum mechanics so you will need to fully understand and document that field.
Whilst of course you are simulating every atom in the universe using humanity's complete understanding of every physical and mathematical model.
This is not provable, it an assumption. Religious people (which account for a large percent the population) claim intelligence and/or consciousness stem from a "spirit" which existed before birth and will continue to exist after death. Also unprovable, by the way.
I think your foundational assertion would have to be rephrased as "Assuming things like God/spirits don't exist, AGI must be possible because we are AGI agents" in order to be true
It's not a question of whether a robot can have a soul, it's a question of how to a) procure a soul and b) bind said soul to a robot both of which seem impossible given or current knowledge
Religion is evidently not relevant in any case. What ChatGPT already does today religious individuals 50 years ago would have near unanimously declared behavior only a "soul" can do.
Only that OP asserted as fact something that is disputed as fact by a large percentage of the population.
> Religion is evidently not relevant in any case.
I think it's relevant. I would venture to say proving AGI is possible is tantamount to proving God doesn't exist (or rather, proving God is not needed in the formation of an intelligent being)
> What ChatGPT already does today religious individuals 50 years ago would have near unanimously declared behavior only a "soul" can do
Some religious people, maybe. But that sort of blanket statement is made all the time "[Religious people] claimed X was impossible, but science proved them wrong!"
In contrast, imagine the scenario of AGI using artificial but biological neurons.
There are less and less people in IT and also Data companies that really care about correctness and efficiency of the solutions. ChatGPT in opinions (not only mine - like I've learned along last few weeks) is getting worse every release. The language gets better, the lies and hallucinations gets better, but being an informative and helpful tool - more like Black Mirrors idea of filling gap after someone who died, not a real improvement in science or social-metrics.