Any filter immediately becomes a tool to limit the number of voters for the opposition.
We already have arguments over what should be considered a felony , gerrymandering county lines, etc.
Seems like requiring a certain level of education would just incentivize more attacks on public education
We even have a citizenship test, for those not born here
In an ideal world, anyone who would be affected by a policy (directly or indirectly) should be allowed to have a say in the policy.
Citizenship seems to be a "good enough" bar for letting people in this country vote on matters of this country.
And as I pointed out, any filter, including citizenship, is turned into a way remove voters who should otherwise have a say.
I mean it would be a huge undertaking etc etc, but there's people and state actors with infinite means to do so.
No, but we should require proof that you _are_ a citizen. And no, a flimsy attestation that certain groups fight tooth and nail against periodic verification of (see the arguments that come up every time the voter rolls need to be purged of the dead, people who’ve moved, or to ensure that no one lied about their citizenship status) isn’t a good solution.
One critical strength of democracy is that it allows voters to remove the current politician - even if that politician would rather not be removed.
Where would you pick your line? Small moves of the line change the size of the disenfranchised group.
And I have to admire your chutzpah of suggesting tests to create a disenfranchised group on an article showing serious flaws with testing... Of course you haven't suggested a single way to fix any flaws. I sincerely hope you are not working in any engineering role.
Citation needed
Your implicit premise is that we vote for policy. Democracy works despite the ma. . . | Hacker News. (n.d.). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41914604What if you did not get the benefit from this public education? Now you're discriminating against the uneducated, who may have their own opinion on education policies that they should have the right to vote on.
While I agree that everyone should have literacy and calculus and all those other skills that we nowadays consider "basic" or "elementary", and everyone should have access to them, if not be required to go to school up to a certain age / level... you can't assume everyone can or does, through no fault of their own.
These would still be considered racist for the same reason a test like the one in the article would be.