It may be fuzzy on the far edges, but any speech that calls for the elimination, marginalizes, dehumanizes or denies human or civil rights of a group of people is right in the heart of the meaning of hate speech.
That definition still leaves huge amounts of space for satire, comedy, political and other forms of protected speech, even "offensive speech".
but you've already lumped together a huge range of behaviours and impacts. Elimination? OK, we can probably broadly define that, but I just heard news reports with quotes of Israelis calling for the elimination of Hamas, and Iran the elimination of Israel. How do we handle that? marginalized? as defined by who? What about marginalizing undesirable behaviours or speech? What does "dehumanize" mean? Who's definition of human or civil rights?
I'd call both of them hate speech without qualification. But between countries, there's no legal system that would rule on speech (only actions, like the ICJ tries to adjudicate).
> What about marginalizing undesirable behaviours or speech?
What is the example of undesirable behavior being undertaken by a group that would warrant their marginalization as a group? I'm having a hard time finding an example of that. Calling out a group of racists or bigots (based on their words) for what they are isn't marginalization.
> What does "dehumanize" mean?
This has a very straightforward definition:
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/dehumanize
> Who's definition of human or civil rights?
In the US context, this is also well defined:
https://www.findlaw.com/civilrights/civil-rights-overview/wh...
Yep, that's bad alright.
> marginalizes, dehumanizes
This is the part which means anything that authorities or other powerful groups need it to.
That seems extremely wrong, especially in this context, given that LLMs make no attempt to formalize "ideas", they're only interested in syntax.
Stating the position "torture is bad" is enough to get you banned from some places (because it's offensive to people who believe that it's okay as long as the victims are less-than-human).
This can be done from both sides. Examples:
Not sufficiently (for whoever) enforcing immigration laws? "Trying to eliminate the majority population, gradual ethnic cleansing".
Talking about deporting illegal immigrants? "The first step on the road to murdering people they don't want in the country."
And if the local judiciary or law enforcement is aligned with the interests of one side or the other, they can stretch the anti hate speech laws to use the legal system against their opponents.
You are seeing this EXACT thing in the middle east right now.
E.g. "X race/gender/sexual orientation are bad for the society for reason Y, and therefore they should be treated with Z (a negative consequence)"
So intending to call out harm because of certain inherent characteristics a group of people have, and such characteristics that are not harmful for the society.
Currently there is an ongoing court case regarding the case where a person criticized and made offensive statements about Muhammad, and if that should count as inciting violence or general harm against Muslims. One side is arguing that any negative statements about Muhammad is veiled statements directed against Muslims as a group, and the other side is arguing it is criticism against the religion and not about people who believe in that religion. People did similar arguments with Monty Python movie Life of Brian.
When it comes to symbols like flags, people often characteristic any action (positive and negative) as a form of hate speech if they dislike it, or as important symbolic gestures when they like it. Burning flags get often called hate speech, and forbidding people from waving flags (including general rules against all flags for specific events) has also been called hate speech.
1. Criticising a religion != hate speech, or generally making fun of or criticising any sort of religious figure like Muhammad or Jesus != hate speech.
2. Calling out for a group of people of certain religion to have X negative consequences = hate speech.
The logic is:
1. Has to be harmful for a certain group of people with certain inherent traits.
2. Has to be harm that would be generally considered harmful by most groups if they were on the receiving end. E.g. reducing pay, sending people out of the country, violence, etc.
Most people would find it harmful to be forced out of their living place, but not all groups would care about how "holidays" are called or find it a basic right.