The first time this happened (that I caught) I had two engineers who were sniping at each other. One was older "Max" and not great at data structure algorithms. The other "Stan" was a decent coder but had a bad attitude and was awful with git. Somehow he thought he could raise his status by getting Max kicked off the team.
I come back from lunch one day and Stan is bitching about a bug in Max's new code that's causing issues. To keep these two from fighting I've been reviewing all of Max's PRs and the line of code Stan is complaining about I know for a fact I checked, and was relieved to see Max got it right the first time. But sure enough, the repo says Max fucked it up.
Twenty minutes of git archaeology later and sure enough, Stan messed up a merge and resolved the conflict wrong, introducing the phantom bug. So I showed him the step by step of my diagnosis and then we had another little talk about using rebase.