Legacy and "good" are different things. I believe I falsified the idea that it's a legacy technique. I actually think it's also a good technique. I also think a lot of other devs agree, they just can't be bothered arguing about it on HN, hence the fact that large high-budget codebases usually seem to use it extensively and aren't switching to some other design.
As for studies, I'd be interested to read those, as most studies of developer productivity I've seen aren't that good.