https://github.com/soimort/you-get/pull/2680/commits/313b8d2...
You do not need to know Python deeply to construct what they are expecting. They’re not actually looking for a unit test or something.
I did. And I looked at all examples of “good commits”, not just the trivial ones.
https://github.com/soimort/you-get/pull/2685/files
That’s already complex for someone unfamiliar with the software (which might nonetheless be able to open a competent bug report).
Perfectly fine rule for a maintainer to have.
How do you currently submit bug reports on e.g. MS Word or Adobe Photoshop? This way is certainly more open than those commonly-deployed software.
What you're saying is even worse, since you’re implying someone could be an expert computer programmer or power user, but because they’re unfamiliar with the specific language this project chose, they are incapable of making good bug reports. That makes no sense.
There are other cases where Goodharts Law fails as well: consider quant firms, where the "metric" used to judge a trader is basically how much money you pull in. Seems to be working fine for them
Seems to make sense