Cost: $29
Promoted plays: 1,800
New Facebook Likes: 31
Mailing List Signups: 24
Sales from Facebook Fans: $24
Sales From Email Signup: $65
Profit: $60
Promotion #2
Cost: $29
Promoted plays: 1,800
New Facebook Likes: 28
Mailing List Signups: 3
Sales from Facebook Fans: $20
Sales From Email Signup: $38
Profit: $29"
That's pretty terrific ROI I'd say. User spent $58 and got 59 FB likes (let's say those would cost $1 each to get via FB), 27 mailing list signups (let's say those would cost $2 each to get through other means), plus an actual $147 in music sales.
So the user spent $58 and got back about $260 in value.
Earbits should be pretty darn happy with that sort of ROI.