I wonder if it will be allowed to expire on schedule and my taxes will go back down. Probably too much to hope for.
But I'm also willing to admit there may be some very solid policy reasons why this is a good idea. I have tried to imagine some, but no luck so far!
What kind of impact did making SALT tax no longer deductable have on the federal government? Did this change the budget noticeably?
You hit it on the nail. That was even part of the pitch, that it would hit blue states harder than red ones.
Even then, I expect the real goal was just catering to the folks with deep pockets. No attempt was made to hide that -- half the tax 'cuts' expire, but the other half are permanent. Guess which half...
Municipalities are their own worst enemies with restrictive zoning and small-minded inability to consolidate services with neighboring districts that don't need so much duplication.
If corporate income taxes are 21%, income is reduced by expenses such as property taxes.
If individual income tax rates are 24%/32%; and a state has a low income tax rate of 5%; then a married couple making $200k earned income, then a salt cap at $10k, pays 25% more in property taxes than the corporation.
So, even if the state and local taxes are massaged to give owners a 25% discount for being owner occupied; they don't.
The idea is not the the state/city needs less services; owner occupied properties often want more services and are willing to pay for it; but now the city can no longer create policy that supports that.
1. It became was more-expensive for individuals to own a house, especially in areas with high local property taxes. (Losing the ability to deduct those payments from their personal federal income bill.)
2. Taxes on corporate profits went down in general, and some portion of those corporations may be in the business of buying housing and then renting them out. (Since companies are taxed on profit rather than income, they already pseudo-deduct property taxes and other expenses.)
That said, those two items don't feel like, er, "two ends of the same see-saw" to me, especially given how #2 is very broad.
Therefore, it becomes beneficial for the (even the same individuals) to invest in corporations that rent out real estate; and removes the ability for the city to use homestead exemptions to help discriminate to encourage owner occupied units.
So you get higher home prices/rents with fewer owner occupied properties, with less incentive for community investment (including property taxes), and fewer levers for the state/municipality to pull.