The Epicurean Dealmaker (@epicureandeal) posted the standard response to your comment a few days ago ("Ready, Fire, Aim"). Prices are calculated as LIBOR + spread. You and I argue over the spread meaning that if I want 185 bp then I'll either ask LIBOR+165 or LIBOR+65 if the base rate went up by a whole 1%.
Check the people who responded to his twitter comments (e.g., @dsquareddigest) for more of the standard back-and-forth here. For example Eurodollar futures hedge the LIBOR so people short LIBOR during the period in question directly lost money.
Tangent: this is something I love about twitter. I imagine the meatspace equivalent would be eavesdropping on some Wall Street people in a bar, or hoping that a variety of voices get heard in the WSJ. But today, on twitter, I can read financial market participants' back & forth to each other about the scandal of the day, using their own terminology and reasoning. Very cool.
How on earth is such a conflict of interest allowed to parade around out in the open?
It's in no-one's interest to admit that systemically important banks have lost the confidence of their counterparties.
The entire entire financial world is built on insider manipulation. Too many examples to list.
Put another way, who is willing to buy or sell according to prices that are open to manipulation (by being pegged to something like LIBOR), and why are they willing to do this? And why shouldn't competition favor produce better alternatives like financial instruments that aren't pegged to any artificial index?
There are those, too, but people want to hedge against the risk that "interest rates" move.
Then they must define "interest rate": is it mortgages in Peoria? Car loans in Manila? 30-year Treasurys? ... Well, how about we use LIBOR.
This only works in economics textbooks. Economic actors never have perfect knowledge is another example.
I think most of these benchmarks are chosen out of expediency at the time, then they become entrenched. The use of the Dollar for oil transactions might be another example.
How many people do you know who /really / understand the world economy? It's the best act of "security through obscurity" combined with "security theatre" ever.