> If its possible and legal for Google, then why not for any and everyone else to also index and offer access to the same data.
Because Craigslist isn't suing Google. If they didn't want Google indexing their stuff, Google would comply.
> Google doesn't get special secondary property rights to privatize public data to the exclusion of anyone else.
They can and do. That's why it's beneficial to set your user agent to Google Bot when browsing news sites.
> Equal access to exchange data and search data is a principle in parallel to the notions of net neutrality.
Full of shit. It takes effort to provide the service that Craigslist does. Claiming that you have a right to that data is wrong, and moreover has already been decided by case law (you can find links in other comments on this page).
> And look at what a 3rd party application (craiggers.com) can do in recreating the whole of Craigslist in a format that gives access to data in a way that is not remotely possible in the legacy Craigslist offering.
There is a reason Craigslist doesn't make that data available - it would reduce the utility for sellers of their website, reducing their revenue and potentially drying up their business. Trying to squeeze it out of Google's cache is still copyright infringement.
> Note, Craiggers does NOT disrupt the existing Craigslist revenue model for Craigslist.
Yes, it does. By scraping craigslist in an attempt to undermine their platform you are eliminating their site's relatively utility for buyers, which eliminates the impetus for sellers to list there.