> For me, social media is the worst thing we ever created.
Calling social media the “worst thing we ever created” as a comment on a social media site is deeply ironic.
I can’t believe how many commenters are assuming these laws will only apply to sites they don’t personally use. The amount of “good riddance” commenting from people inviting heavy handed internet ID checking regulation because they can’t imagine it would ever affect them personally is really scary.
I completely disagree.
The core of HN is not self promotion, narration, or comparison - the very things driving teen suicides up from social media use.
I further suggest most of the replies to my original comment are willfully ignoring the data the Australian govt is citing for these bans, and what psychologists worldwide are citing.
None of the discussion here so far even touches on a possible solution to a problem that is driving measurable deaths.
Instead we have a collection of false equivalence and abdication of social responsibility by big tech, which is fairly on brand for hn and frankly intellectually lazy from my perspective.
63C Age-restricted social media platform (1) For the purposes of this Act, age-restricted social media platform means: (a) an electronic service that satisfies the following conditions: (i) the sole purpose, or a significant purpose, of the service is to enable online social interaction between 2 or more end-users; (ii) the service allows end-users to link to, or interact with, some or all of the other end-users; (iii) the service allows end-users to post material on the service;
I would say that HN is covered under that.
https://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/download/legislation/bi...
You are quite shortsighted if you can't see the possible outcomes of such a far-reaching and anti-democratic law.
This has too many chilling effects. It's so far from perfect it's crazy.
By the letter of the law any service even allowing only one-on-one conversations is covered. It's obvious to me that these secondary effects are by design.
Open communication is the most important thing that democracy needs, and this is a clear attack on it.
Also can we not recognise that social media can have good effects as well? https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-12-01/social-media-ban-unde...
Murdoch media is losing it's power and fighting back.
Why not restrict the algorithms they're permitted to use, to fight echo chambers?
That might actually have a chance of helping every person, not only <16 year olds?
If protecting kids from porn is the objective, the most obvious thing to do would be to require age verification for porn sites, not some other random websites that happen to have occasional porn.
Ironically, kids will now have to visit much more hardcore sites (4chan etc - ones without age verification) if they want to socialise online. The effects will be similar to banning alcohol, it doesn't decrease demand, just pushes it elsewhere creating worse problems along the way.
See: perverse incentives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive#Examples_of...
The internet was wild before social media but somehow the weird stuff remained fringe before recommendation algorithms and the perverse incentives that emerged from recommendation algorithms and content creation meant that feeds became an on ramp to all kinds of nasty things
I'm not exactly a greybeard but I remember when happy slapping was a viral phenomenon but that seems pretty tame by comparison these days