⸻
1. Yes, this is mathematically the reason why black holes are referred to as singularities.
⸻
1. Yes, this is mathematically the reason why black holes are referred to as singularities.
f'(c) = lim_{h → 0} (f(c + h) - f(c))/h
The definition would not make sense if f wasn't defined at c (note the "f(c)" in the numerator). For instance, it can't be applied to your f(x) = (x² - 1)/(x - 1) at x = 1, because f(1) is not defined.
And it's a standard result (even stated in Calc 1 classes) that if a function is differentiable at a point, then it's continuous there. For example:
5.2 Theorem. Let f be defined on [a, b]. If f is differentiable at a point x ∈ [a, b], then f is continuous at x.
(Walter Rudin, "Principles of Mathematical Analysis", 3rd edition, p. 104)
Or:
Theorem 2.1 If f is differentiable at x = a, then f is continuous at x = a.
(Robert Smith and Roland Minton, "Calculus -Early Transcendentals", 4th edition, p. 140)
It's true that your f(x) = (x² - 1)/(x - 1) has a removable discontinuity at x = 1, since if we define g(x) = f(x) for x ≠ 1 and g(1) = 2, then g is continuous. Was this what you meant?
and yes, by defining a new function with that hole explicitly filled in with a defined value to make it continuous is the typical prescription. It does not imply the derivative exists for the other function as the other post posits.
That's right. In the example f(x) = (x² - 1)/(x - 1) for x ≠ 1, if we further define f(1) = 0, the function is now defined at x = 1, but discontinuous there.
> ... if the limit of the derivative from both sides of the discontinuity exists and is equal, the derivative exists.
(You probably mean "both sides of the point", since if there's a discontinuity there the derivative can't exist.) Your point that, if the left and right-hand limits both exist and are equal, then the derivative exists (and equals their common value) is true for all limits.
Also, there's a difference between the use of the word "continuous" in calc courses and in topology. In calc courses where functions tend to take real numbers to real numbers, a function may be said to be "not continuous" at a point where it isn't defined. So f(x) = 1/(x - 2) is "not continuous at 2". But in topology, you only consider continuity for points in the domain of the function. So since the (natural) domain of f(x) = 1/(x - 2) is x ≠ 2, the function is continuous everywhere (that it's defined).
However, you could also (probably) define the derivative as lim_{h->0} (f(c+h) - f(c-h))/2h, so without needing f(c) to be defined. But that's not standard.
Although this gives the right answer whenever f is differentiable at c, it can wrongly think that a function is differentiable when it isn't, as for the absolute-value function at c = 0.
It's called "removable" because it can be removed by a continuous extension - the original function itself is still formally discontinuous (of course, one would often "morally" treat these as the same function, but strictly speaking they're not). An important theorem in complex analysis is that any continuous extension at a single point is automatically a holomorphic (= complex differentiable) extension too.
>which is why they’re defined via limits
They're defined via studying f(x+h) - f(x) with a limit h -> 0. But, your example is taking two limits, h->0 and x->1, simultaneously. This is not the same thing.
A function is continuous at x = a if it is differentiable at x = a.
You do understand the concept, but your precision in the definitions is lacking.