It isn't like the only two options are "the Christian conception of a soul" and "the atheists rejection of the conception of a soul".
If you sneak away, go through the forest and come back, you will see a very nuanced picture of who is saying what. For example you found a stream. Someone may not mention a stream, but from his tale you will see that he indeed was there, but in winter and missed the stream just a bit. Or someone may loudly claim there is a stream, but you will clearly see that the person never was there and is only trying to persuade you to buy a flask.
But if you never was there all these tales will look same to you. This guy says this and that guys says that; how to decide? Logically? But is it clearly impossible to merely take all those words, somehow analyze them and get a correct answer. The clues one should look for are not in the contents of the tale.
This "foundational belief" is nonsensical. How about the belief in self-determination and responsibility for one's own actions?
Am I denying that aliens exist? I’m not a native speaker but it sounds weird to me.