I'm not sure what you mean by "genuine". My criticisms are sincere, as always, though of course that is no guarantee that they are correct. I've certainly made every effort to ensure that they are, but I'm fallible. Do you think they are incorrect?

If you don't find my perspective of interest, you of course have no obligation to read it, but if I didn't think something like my comments were worth reading, I wouldn't have written them. It's true that they're longer than your post—but that's because your post is unfinished!

Sometimes my writing falls short of the mark, but in this case, other people seem to have found my comment worthwhile, and I think that it turned out to be much higher quality than I had hoped. This time I think you're missing out by skimming.