Not having to remunerate failed founders and starting employees for their effort is a cornerstone of the VC business model.
Greedy optimization can also get you stuck in local minima. Why does any investor participate in VC? As an asset class it underperforms. There's something more that motivates people than return. Cool factor, bragging rights, and also I think a concern for growth and the macro outlook.
In my model the reserved pool of shares for failed founders would come out of the winning founders' pool. It's spreading risk across founders, not diminishing the stake of investors.
In the main, VC LPs put money into VC firms because they have portfolio allocation constraints for decorrelated investments, is how I understand it. It's definitely not out of charity.