Hacker News Reader

Comment by calpaterson | Hacker News Reader

In many (all?) unix shells, globs are expanded by the shell before being passed to the program.

   'ls *.jpg'

is passed expanded to 'ls 1.jpg 2.jpg 3.jpg' BEFORE ls is run. This choice means that if a program wants to use another style of regular expression (ie: pcre), it must be enclosed in quotes on the shell, ie:

  "ls | grep -P '.*jpg'"

View on HN

Yes, that's globbing, but I was wondering what the OP meant by argument expansion. It could be just globbing, or include globbing but extend to variable expansion, braces, command substitution... It's hard to put a case that having the shell do these things is the right way to do it without understanding the OP's point clearly.

Minor point: if the glob doesn't match it isn't expanded. Sometimes useful. I rarely escape scp commands for instance.

See `failglob' elsewhere on this page. What you suggest is sometimes useful but also sometimes wrong and hard to spot because the glob might match locally and one not realise.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com