An LLM that can translate english into formal proof, a logic engine that can apply law to events and situations, and then a translator that can turn the result back into English should be achievable.
It all comes back to "trust but verify." Until it outperforms humans with less mistakes, it needs an editor reviewing the work closely. The main problem with current LLM output and humans right now is that the LLM outputs such verbose text, humans are overwhelmed and just go with it, instead of applying the time it saved them to reviewing the work, they just move on.