What I think/feel/sense/intuit is that kindergarten, preschool and the first years of school should focus entirely on how to interact with other people one-on-one and in groups with respect for everyone including yourself.
I suspect there is a lot to learn from from what we are trying to develop around sexual consent wrt setting and enforcing boundaries.
With more recent societal understanding around mental health, generational trauma, neurodivergence I think it would be possible to achieve quite big changes around this topic.
- X bullies Y
- Y is troubled by this, involves authority A
- A is not willing to intervene for any amount of reasons (non-exhaustive list: thinks it's an X-said-Y-said situation, doesn't want to, does not see behavior of X as out of place, likes X, doesn't like Y, is also bullied by X, etc.), gives useless advice that X and Y should settle matters between themselves
- Y lashes out
- both are punished (occasionally just Y)
- Y is physically removed from the situation (quits, goes to a different school)
Which part can be improved from the point of Y to get a more favorable outcome?
Also you're completely missing the bystanders B in your analysis. Without them there is no bullying. Then it just becomes robbery or molestation.
Maybe we need more bullies, not less, to make our system more resilience against them.
Agreed, Bs are the key here, and it connects neatly to another concept that I believe is misunderstood: the fight, flight, freeze and fawn response (from psychology)
While lions sure are dangerous that problem was solved by evolution by becoming social group creatures so the big danger is being left out of the group. That's where the imminent/perceived danger is: being alone puts us at risk.