Why would that be fairer? We can assume they did incorporate all learnings and optimizations they made post gpt-4 launch, no?
It'd be weird to release a distilled version without ever releasing the base undistilled version.
If this huge model has taken months to pre-train and was expected to be released before, say, o3-mini, you could definitely have some last-minute optimizations in o3-mini that were not considered at the time of building the architecture of gpt-4.5.